Few desserts are as timeless as a homemade pie. From flaky, buttery crusts to fresh fruit fillings and classic cream pies, there’s something special about finding local pie shops in Massachusetts that still make them from scratch.
Across Cape Cod, the South Coast, and Greater Boston, Massachusetts is home to plenty of bakeries and specialty shops serving up pies worth seeking out. Whether you’re craving a traditional apple pie, a slice of blueberry, or something a little different, these 14 local spots are worth adding to your list.
Pie Shops on Cape Cod, Massachusetts
Cape Cod has no shortage of local bakeries, and some have been making pies for generations. From dedicated pie shops to neighborhood bakeries, these five stops offer plenty of reasons to save room for dessert.
1. Pie in the Sky in Woods Hole, Falmouth
A Woods Hole staple, Pie in the Sky Bakery & Café has been serving scratch-made baked goods since 1982. Located near the Steamship Authority ferry terminal and the Shining Sea Bikeway, it’s an easy stop while exploring the village. Its pie selection includes apple, blueberry, cherry, mixed berry, pecan, and seasonal favorites like strawberry rhubarb and apple cranberry. Pair a slice with a freshly roasted coffee and enjoy it in the café’s courtyard.
2. Cape Cod Pie Shop in East Falmouth
Formerly known as Pies à la Mode, Cape Cod Pie Shop specializes in small-batch pies made with quality ingredients and traditional recipes. The shop bakes a variety of sweet and savory pies daily, with large, small, and handheld options. Special requests are welcome, making it a great place to find something for a gathering or bring home for later. Call ahead to reserve your favorites.
3. Centerville Pie Company in Centerville & Sandwich
Centerville Pie Company has become one of Cape Cod’s best-known names in homemade pies. Founded in 2009, the business grew from a small local pie shop into a nationally recognized brand. Its menu features everything from classic apple, blueberry, cherry, and peach pies to signature creations like Cape Cod Crunch Pie. The shop is also known for its savory offerings, including its famous chicken pie.
4. Marion’s Pie Shop in Chatham
Marion’s Pie Shop has been part of the Chatham community since 1947. What began with Marion selling homemade chicken pot pies from her own kitchen has grown into a beloved local bakery. Today, the shop offers a wide selection of fresh fruit pies, savory pies, baked treats, and prepared entrées. It’s a longtime Cape Cod favorite for anyone who appreciates traditional, homemade baking.
5. Cottage St Bakery in Orleans
Cottage Street Bakery is a local favorite in Orleans, known for its extensive selection of baked goods and homemade pies. Its fruit pie menu includes apple, blueberry, cherry, peach, strawberry peach, apple cranberry, and four-season berry varieties. You’ll also find seasonal and cream pies. Stop in for a pie to take home or browse the bakery’s other offerings!
Pie Shops on the South Coast, Massachusetts
The South Coast has a few pie destinations of its own, including a longtime bakery favorite and a Fairhaven restaurant known for its homemade apple pie.
6. Nancy’s Bakery in Somerset
Nancy’s Bakery offers a variety of classic pies available to order online. Its selection includes apple, blueberry, very berry, pecan, pumpkin, lemon meringue, and several cream and custard varieties. With multiple sizes available, there’s something for everything from a casual dessert at home to a larger gathering. It’s a great Somerset stop for anyone looking to bring home a traditional bakery pie.
7. Sweet as Pie Pantry in Somerset
Sweet as Pie Pantry is a locally loved Somerset bakery dedicated to homemade sweet and savory pies. Its dessert offerings have included traditional apple and strawberry rhubarb, along with specialty fruit combinations like blueberry pear and bumbleberry. The shop is also known for its savory dinner pies, making it a stop for both dessert and comfort food. With new ownership taking over the longtime pie shop, it’s another South Coast destination worth keeping on your radar.
8. The Phoenix Restaurant in Fairhaven
Known for its breakfast menu, The Phoenix Restaurant also makes homemade pies from scratch. Its selection includes classic apple pie filled with cinnamon-spiced apples, along with savory favorites like French meat pie and chicken pot pie. It’s a little different from a traditional bakery stop, but a worthwhile addition for pie lovers exploring Fairhaven.
Pie Shops in Greater Boston, Massachusetts
Greater Boston is home to several specialty pie shops and established neighborhood bakeries. Whether you’re looking for a traditional fruit pie or a more creative flavor combination, these six destinations have something to offer.
9. Drive-By Pies in Brookline
Drive-By Pies is a neighborhood bake shop specializing in sweet and savory pies. Its menu features a variety of nine-inch pies, including apple, peach, blueberry, apple cranberry crumb, and pear with salted caramel. Strawberry rhubarb is another seasonal favorite. The shop also offers cream pies, mini pies, quiches, and savory options, making it a great stop for more than just dessert.
10. Petsi Pies in Somerville
Since opening in 2003, Petsi Pies has built a following for its handmade pies and pastries. Its menu features year-round favorites like classic apple, wild Maine blueberry, mixed berry, and cherry crumb. There are also vegan fruit pie options, including apple, blueberry, mixed berry, and cherry. Pies are available in multiple sizes, making it easy to pick one up for yourself or share with a group.
11. Bova’s Bakery in Boston
A North End institution since 1926, Bova’s Bakery is known for its traditional Italian baked goods, pastries, and classic pies. Its pie selection includes apple, blueberry, cherry, pumpkin, and custard, alongside specialty options like ricotta pie. Some varieties are seasonal or holiday-only, so it’s worth checking with the bakery before visiting. Open around the clock, Bova’s is a Boston bakery worth knowing.
12. Sweet Teez Bakery in Dorchester
Sweet Teez Bakery offers a selection of traditional pies alongside its cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and other baked goods. Its nine-inch pie menu includes apple, blueberry, cherry, pumpkin, sweet potato, and key lime. Mini pies are also available by the dozen, making them a fun option for parties, celebrations, or sharing with friends.
13. Modern Pastry Shop in Boston & Medford
Modern Pastry Shop has been a familiar name among Boston-area dessert lovers for generations. Best known for its Italian pastries, the bakery also offers a selection of pies, including fruit, ricotta, chocolate cream, and traditional seasonal varieties. With locations in Boston’s North End and Medford, it’s another local destination for bringing home something sweet.
14. Sugar Baking Co. in West Roxbury
Sugar Baking Co. is a neighborhood bakery in West Roxbury with a dedicated pie menu. Its offerings include apple, blueberry, cherry, and crumb pies, along with lemon meringue, pecan, banana cream, and key lime. Vegan apple crumb, blueberry crumb, and cherry crumb pies are also available.
Find Your Next Favorite Pie Shop in Coastal Massachusetts
From longtime Cape Cod bakeries to specialty pie shops in Greater Boston, these local businesses prove that a good pie is always worth seeking out. Each brings something different to the table, whether it’s a traditional fruit filling, a family recipe, or a creative take on a classic.
The next time you’re exploring the coast or looking for something sweet to bring home, consider stopping by one of these local spots. You might just find your new favorite pie!
Pie selections, seasonal flavors, and availability can change throughout the year. Contact each bakery directly for current offerings and ordering information.